FHA Secure, Alonso Quixano, and Windmills

When FHA Secure was announced by the Bush Administration back in August of 2007, the FHA folks were perplexed. I know because I called them. First of all, FHA had already been doing unlimited CLTV refinances for a couple of years. Second, you didn’t have to be in default on your mortgage to qualify. And third, nobody had any idea what the hell the administration was talking about.

Those familiar with the Cervantes classic Don Quixote will remember Alonso Quixano, the county gentleman who descends into fantasy and reconstructs a farcical reality in which he fights unwinnable battles with imaginary enemies. The familiar phrase “tilting at windmills” has become iconic for the persistent pursuit of futile endeavors.

Still With Me?

Watching the administration and Alphonso Jackson of HUD descend into their own farcical reality has been disappointing. Like the great novel’s second half, the tale of FHA Secure appears to have evolved into a deliberate deception most painful to those for whom FHA Secure initially appeared to offer some hope.

Peter Miller, whose terrific watch dog blog FHA Mortgage Guide keeps close tabs on FHA financing, brings forth the disappointing reality of the statistics vs. the claims, as reported by HUD itself.

Despite the hundreds of thousands of homeowners Jackson claims to have helped (you will note that the these numbers are always in reference to FHA loans in general), “the glaring failure of the FHASecure program,” as Miller points out in his recent post FHA Mortgages at Mid-Year: Real Numbers Comes Out, is that “just 1,729 delinquent conventional borrowers have been helped in a period of six months.”

That’s a far cry from from the spin.

Share This